BIBS x Liberty Pacifier Size 1 vs Size 2: Which to Choose?
By UK Baby Centre | Published: 2026-11-02
Category: Comparisons
Compare BIBS x Liberty latex pacifiers in Size 1 and Size 2. Learn when to move up, how age guidance works, and which size suits your baby's stage.
Quick answer
Start with Size 1 for a newborn, because most newborns prefer the smaller shield and nipple, then move to Size 2 around six months if your baby seems ready. Both sizes are the same latex pacifier in different Liberty prints, so the choice is about fit and stage, not features.
What actually differs between Size 1 and Size 2
The two BIBS x Liberty pacifiers in this comparison share the same latex nipple material and the same Liberty Strawberries & Cream print. The meaningful difference is the size: Size 1 is recommended from 0+ months, while Size 2 is recommended from 6+ months. BIBS notes that all sizes can be introduced from birth, so the age labels are a guide rather than a strict rule. That gives you room to follow your baby's cues, but it also means you should not treat the month number as an automatic switch date.
The trade-off: smaller fit versus longer use
Size 1 gives a smaller, lighter pacifier that suits a newborn's mouth and reduces the bulk of a larger shield against a tiny face. The trade-off is that you may need to size up sooner if your baby outgrows the fit or the pacifier starts looking cramped. Size 2 is built for the six-month-plus stage and can last longer, but putting a larger size on a very small newborn may feel like more pacifier than they need. Neither size is universally better; the right choice depends on your baby's age and comfort.
Why latex matters for this decision
Both options use latex, a natural material that feels softer and more flexible than silicone. Some parents find latex suits newborns better because it adapts to the mouth, but latex also wears differently and should be checked regularly for signs of damage. If you are comparing latex vs silicone pacifier for newborns, remember that this BIBS x Liberty pair is latex only, so the size decision is separate from the material decision.
Key trade-offs at a glance
- Newborn fit: Size 1 is the smaller option and is recommended from 0+ months, so it is the safer first choice for a newborn. If your baby is under six months, start with Size 1 unless a health professional advises otherwise.
- When to move up: BIBS recommends Size 2 from 6+ months, but all sizes can be introduced from birth. Move up when your baby seems to need more room or the Size 1 looks small. Use the six-month mark as a prompt to check fit, not an automatic deadline.
- Longevity: Size 2 can be used for longer as your baby grows, while Size 1 may be outgrown sooner. If you want one pacifier to last through the second half of the first year, Size 2 is the more forward-looking choice.
Product facts
- Bibs x Liberty Colour Strawberries & Cream Latex Pacifier (2 Pack, Size 1) - Ivory Mix: Size 1 is recommended for 0+ months. It is the natural starting point for a newborn and gives you a smaller fit from day one.
Bibs x Liberty Colour Strawberries & Cream Latex Pacifier (2 Pack, Size 1) - Ivory Mix - Bibs x Liberty Colour Strawberries & Cream Latex Pacifier (2 Pack, Size 2) - Ivory Mix: Size 2 is recommended for 6+ months. It suits the older baby stage and can be introduced when your baby seems ready for a larger pacifier.
Bibs x Liberty Colour Strawberries & Cream Latex Pacifier (2 Pack, Size 2) - Ivory Mix
Which size is right for your baby?
Choose Size 1 if
- You have a newborn or a baby under six months.
- Your baby is small and a larger pacifier seems bulky.
Choose Size 2 if
- Your baby is under six months and comfortable with Size 1.
- You want the smallest possible pacifier for a very young newborn.
